First of all, just because I have one of the longest-running Keith Olbermann fan pages (olbermann.freeservers.com) doesn't mean anyone cares what I think or that I have any special insight into his stunning "ESPN: Mea Culpa" column in Salon this week. But being something of a student of his career and his journalistic voice, it's hard to leave the column alone. Because it rambles, wanders, and raises almost as many questions as it answers, it will take some time, follow-up columns from him, and feedback to put it into context. But here's my initial thoughts.
1) Olbermann gave too much ground. Whereas he simplistically saw ESPN management as too evil and himself as too righteous while working there (as he now admits), now he simplistically sees management as too righteous and himself too culpable. Granted, he stands by everything he says in Michael Freeman's scathing book, but says it must now be taken with this grain of salt: he was so insecure about his personality and his career that he impulsively blamed everyone else and was blind to his own problems--his conversations with Freeman were, Olbermann says, "the ultimate act of somebody who lived in terror of being blamed." This may obscure the fact that Olbermann was a moral fixture in a 90s environment at ESPN where rapid expansion into a multimedia corporate empire and residual sexism and rampant sexual harassment in the Bristol subculture seemed to sway the broadcasting colossus to the point where few within it seemed to be guided by much of an independent moral compass. Olbermann's presence was in part a redeeming one--or at least an aggravating one, sometimes nobly so and sometimes not. In his column, he sells himself short.
2) The column confirms what many at ESPN, according to Freeman's book, believed: that Olbermann was a tortured genius, with psychological issues in addition to award-winning talent. But what they assumed to be a matter of insatiable ego may simply have been a case of massive insecurity. I'll leave it to Dr. Phil to do the pop psych--actually, you have to wonder about the appropriateness of publishing this kind of intimate introspection in a forum like Salon--it really sounds like he's on a therapist's couch (and a direct letter to friends and enemies at ESPN would have seemed more sincere). But it is a lesson in how the broadcasting world is a jungle of titanic egos, dizzying stress, complex office politics, all magnified by the lens of the camera.
3) Some are tempted to see the column as an indirect (or direct; Olbermann says he'd like to host a show once or twice a week) plea for a job at ESPN. It probably isn't that simple, and Olbermann has never been that tacky. Still, one can imagine cooler heads prevailing in the next few months or years, given that there's been this much time to cool and that Olbermann for the first time is offering an olive branch. Sentimentality aside, the two parties need each other--ESPN needs more distinctive anchoring after several years of so-what cookie-cutter youngsters and a proliferation of studio shows that has diluted its flagship product. And Olbermann seems ready for a return to visibility. But his letter seems to illustrate just how oblivious outside observers are to the dynamics of broadcasting politics.
Well, this is just the first draft of history. It will be interesting to see how ESPN, particularly ex-partner Dan Patrick, responds to the column, and if ESPN and Olbermann are able to mend fences, or even find, under the rubble, the moorings those fences were in before their, um, intense 1997 parting.
http://www.salon.com/news/sports/col/olbermann/2002/11/17/meaculpa/
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
About Me
Labels
- 4 (14)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2002
(559)
-
▼
November
(61)
- • History&Today: Thanksgiving edition • The menu f...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: benison \BEH-nuh-sun...
- Seen at the Globe&Mail's Social Studies, clipped f...
- Earlier in Slate, Virginia Heffernan wrote that "E...
- I'm getting the Wall Street Journal on a trial sub...
- This is an interesting spin on the Augusta Nationa...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: lacuna \lu-KOO-nuh o...
- • Weekend Reading • Previous Reading "An Animal's...
- On Writing: One of my favorite columnists, Anna Qu...
- American politics is nearly a tie ball game, says ...
- Rick Telander says there's more than meets the eye...
- • Places&Culture from ST. PETERSBURG, Russia --...
- • Number of the Day: 1.7 Unemployment rate, in per...
- First of all, just because I have one of the longe...
- Halls of Fame aren't what they used to be. To evok...
- Love the mitten state: Says a friend on a group e-...
- • History&Today File Lewis and Clark were all the ...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: flagrant \FLAY-grunt...
- • Quote of the Day "A football is a prolate spher...
- • Faith&Culture: Today's NY Times ridicules Alabam...
- Thought of the day: ambitious service: an oxymoron...
- • History&Today: Only now are we learning how frai...
- • Places&Culture from IRBID, JORDAN -- If you as...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: garner 1 a : gr...
- Get this: My Big Fat Greek Wedding is now the high...
- Mitch Albom questions the idea that we need the 20...
- • Urban Issues Watch: The Democratic party may be ...
- When Halloween goes fundamentalist, in a new docum...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: kaput 1 : utterl...
- • Number of the Day: 2 Percent of cable viewers wh...
- Latest Tribune article: On restaurants and terrori...
- That ringing in your ears? It’s from watching prim...
- Speaking of imagination, a letter writer to MediaN...
- It's the imagination, stupid. Imagination is the p...
- This term is so overused by sportscasters who don'...
- Says Catholic blogger Peter Nixon: "Pro-life act...
- The Chicago globalization protesters marched peace...
- Thought of the Day: God's will and self-amplificat...
- Revisited: The problem with polls. In September I ...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: voluble \VAHL-yuh-bu...
- NFL parity vs NFL mediocrity. Only one game this w...
- • Sunday Clippings from my e-mail files, including...
- From my file, this e-mail exchange with Virginia P...
- After interviewing him earlier this week, I was gi...
- • Dispatch from the North: My friend Nathan Vander...
- • Urban Issues Watch from the NY Times: It was a...
- • Architecture Watch The downside of magnificent a...
- • Places&Culture File from In the high mountains...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: debacle \dee-BAH-kul...
- Please, please, no Contract With America II ! The...
- • Media&Culture File from Bias or laziness? Seem...
- ACROSS THE board, this has been a dismal campaign,...
- Less democracy, please. I'm looking up endorsement...
- Continuing today's Election Day theme, this patrio...
- A fitting entry for Election Day, given my cynical...
- • Mailbox: Dan Johnson-Weinberger of the Chicago o...
- Thought of the day: when is cynicism too much of a...
- • Money&Culture File from McDONALD'S may serve H...
- • Places&Culture from the Since 1914, the year ...
- • Urban Issues Watch from The Anaheim Angels' s...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: utile \YOO-tul or YO...
-
▼
November
(61)
No comments:
Post a Comment