Thought of the Day: the tension between democracy and power.
America was founded as the anti-Britain, rejecting hierarchy and elitism in favor of democratic ideals. That was the idea anyway (see the Dec. of Independence). It was part ideology, part geography--the new continent had so much more land mass that the equation of land ownership with power no longer made sense: there was enough breathing room for anybody to be anyone they wanted, own as much land as they wanted, and escape from the tight, stuffy social hierarchy of Britain. Hierarchy works better on a small continent than in an vast, untamed new wilderness. Then again, no one was stuffier or more elite than the Founding Fathers--a well-educated, aristocratic breed who valued deference, looked down upon women, and calculated slaves to be 3/5 of of a person. Egalitarian these guys were not.
Since then our economic ideals have always seemed to clash with our democratic ones--we don't really want egalitarianism--anyone being just as important, having just as much power, as anyone else--we just vaguely think we sort of want it. Otherwise we wouldn't so laud the powerful and envy the rich. Otherwise we wouldn't view the poor as an undeserving, underachieving lot that just has to work hard, the American way, in order to prosper (I would submit most of the poor are hard-working, and most of the rich are not and some of them never were). I was re-reading Anna Deavere Smith's Talk to Me and came across this quote from Hayden White, professor at the University of California at Santa Cruz:
The assumption is that the free market and democracy go hand in hand. If you buy into the free market, you have to take a certain amount of unemployment, a certain amount of exploitation, a certain amount of corruption, and so forth. It has nothing to do with democracy. ...That's been the greatest triumph of Western capitalism, to identify democracy with the free market.
Insert Enron rant here. Now, of course our economic mechanisms look good compared to the tyranny of Communist and dictator states, and I don't want to downplay that. I'm just saying that I think we value power more than democracy would suggest we would: if we really believed "all men [sic] are created equal," we wouldn't willingly play politics so much in our workplaces, our homes, our churches, heck, our softball leagues. We value seniority, putting in your dues. I was comiserating with a reporter here at the Tribune about how the mentality is that you graduate to the Tribune from other places, not necessarily that you are a better writer than someone with less newspaper experience, which some major newspaper reporters indeed are not. Then I was thinking about this scenefrom Mr. Holland's Opus the other night where Mr. Holland is waiting in the lunch line in his first day of school, and the football coach comes along and tells him to move to the front of the line: teachers don't wait with the students. "High school is not a democracy," the coach says. We value these imbalances in power, however small a scale they may be on. We function according to seniority, putting in your dues, earning it. Sometimes that has little or nothing to do with equality.
Previous Thought
Footnote:This tension between equality and elitism has throbbed through American political thought. Walter Lippman was one of the great American journalists, and yet he believed news should come from an oligarchy of elite journalists--ministers of culture. As I wrote before, do we really want everyone to vote? Similarly, look at Argentina--this creep is democratically elected, and the U.S. supports a coup that removes him (he's back now). We're saying, we, an elite few, know better than the masses--there is no inherent wisdom in democratic decisions (as I believe Tocqueville put it: the tyranny of the majority).
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
About Me
Labels
- 4 (14)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2002
(559)
-
▼
August
(153)
- • Money&Culture File...or is that Money&Candy? Nes...
- Comics are suffering the end of a stand-up boom, s...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: will-o'-the-wisp \wil-...
- This says it well (click for larger image). As I'v...
- • Media&Culture File It's a frightening new world ...
- Good to see my alma mater, Calvin College, show up...
- • Sports&Culture File: ESPN.com's Bill Simmons kee...
- • Link of the Day: www.canada.com/technology/webju...
- Thought of the day: Does God care about our feelin...
- Watched West Side Story in Grant Park last night, ...
- • History&Today: I meant to post this earlier from...
- Architecture footnote: For goodness sake, says Car...
- • Architecture Watch I just recently encountered t...
- Latest Trib piece: On TheraDate on the front of to...
- • Places&Culture from HICKMAN, Ky. — There have...
- My last two weeks at the Tribune, and the work is ...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: apotheosis \uh-pah-t...
- Morning news from Bearing bottled water, cameras...
- Weekend reading: One of the most thoughtful religi...
- Will takes issue with the Rick Shenkman e-mail at ...
- The baseball strike could silence the legendary vo...
- An e-mail response at Slate to Virginia Hefferman'...
- Railroads the route to post-Cold War diplomacy? Fr...
- What do to with Enron charity donations? ... Hurri...
- One week after the 25th anniversary of his death, ...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: babblative \BAB-luh-...
- • Number of the Day: 5 Percentage below which vaca...
- Thought of the day: though elitist, a down-to-eart...
- Greg Budzban, a mathematics professor at the U of...
- Do you suppose David Slade has a busy job, or is a...
- • Family&Culture File: Michael Lewis, Slate One o...
- • Number of the Day: 1,500 number of wallets lost ...
- EU to pry lid off French perfume industry secrets ...
- Bonus thought (boy, is my brain burbling brillianc...
- Thought of the day: change the world? start by mak...
- Last night, covering an Elvis-impersonator concert...
- Headlines presented here without comment. It's Mak...
- Says CNN's Jeff Greenfield in In the late summer...
- • Places&Culture File: The results are in. Walkin...
- • Quote of the Day: "I have no problem whatsoever ...
- Um, remember the Pentagon? You know, where 184 peo...
- Boom? Bust? Both? Here's why I'm so freaking confu...
- Notebook Reader is back, after a hiatus, of which ...
- Thought of the Day: would we be better of if every...
- • Money&Culture from this morning's newsstand: "B...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: ambrosia \am-BROH-zhuh...
- • Link of the Day: www.politicalpredictions.org "H...
- Recycled Thought of the Day: One of my college men...
- • History&Today It's the 25th anniversary of the d...
- • Blog Watch: The latest blog headlines being link...
- It's good, but unlikely, to see the staid old NY T...
- Latest Trib piece: another of my valuable contribu...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: canard \kuh-NARD\ 1...
- • Places&Culture from LAKE LOUISE VILLAGE, Alber...
- • Quote of the Day: "The hinge of a door is never ...
- Letter from an ex-dot-commer: Today is my last da...
- • History&Today: On the 945th anniversary of Macbe...
- They're practicing for tomorrow's air show here on...
- One liberal and one conservative rant for today: F...
- WILL HAS A WEBLOG: http://refvem.blogspot.com/ Br...
- Important follow-up to my breakdown of personal me...
- Architecture Watch: Manhattan's Citicorp Center ge...
- • Word of the Day from M-W: tatterdemalion \tat-...
- Never mind, someone stole my pool car. So... Thou...
- out of the office until this afternoon; re-enjoy t...
- • Quote of the Day: "Preach the Gospel at all tim...
- The slow but necessary death of the college lectur...
- " alt="Vanilla Coke" HSPACE=5 NOSAVE align=LEFT bo...
- Thought of the day: time and worship "I like conne...
- • Word of the Day from M-W: purfle \PER-ful\ t...
- • Money&Culture File Now is the time that gold—sol...
- Consumer Reports does the math on book buying and ...
- Chicago Architecture Watch: 311 S. Wacker changes ...
- A related thought to below: I've noticed a couple ...
- Thought of the Day: the tension between democracy ...
- • Word of the Day from M-W: perpend \per-PEND\ ...
- • Places&Culture from "Last year we did only 50...
- • Quote of the Day: "Don't worry about the world c...
- Meager offerings here today, I know (in quantity b...
- No, there aren't any pirates in Pittsburgh, says A...
- It's true, says the stellar urban legends site Sno...
- It's a movie kind of day (see below...): Saw A Few...
- Watched Mr. Holland's Opus with my wife last night...
- Word of the Day from M-W: palmary \PAL-muh-ree o...
- A scientific breakdown of Signs from • In 1991, ...
- • Link of the Day: www.coolsig.com You know those ...
- Less than a month until the first anniversary of S...
- Thought of the Day: when to go to war? Right now t...
- Word of the Day from M-W: oneiric \oh-NYE-rik\ ...
- Why the Trib, for all my beefs about it, will alwa...
- Only You Can Prevent Suicide: From a memo last wee...
- P.J. O'Rourke interview in "on the Middle East, t...
- Morning news from Buffeted by the economic slowd...
- • Link of the Day: www.oxymoronlist.com You may ha...
- Is it just me, or is there something a little inco...
- China's hover-train highlights the weekend edition...
- Let the Pulitzer nominations begin: My sidebar wit...
- Thought of the day: religious freedom We were foun...
- • Word of the Day from M-W: mordacious 1 : biting ...
- • Places&Culture File As a journalist and cultural...
-
▼
August
(153)
No comments:
Post a Comment