Nicholas Kristof's column this morning on ideology and vitriol is a relevant followup to my post last week on ambivalence. What he doesn't address, though, is the conventional wisdom that partisan loyalty is, overall, in decline among Americans. Is that still true? Or are moderates just more decisive now? Or are extremists just more outspoken? (And are liberals really getting more secular and conservatives more religious? I thought the heyday of the "Religious Right" had mostly waned, and more evangelicals voted for Gore than for Clinton.)
That ambivalence posting was prompted by a recent offer I got to write some newspaper op-eds. My problem with op-eds is that I hate the sanctimonious and presumptuous tone in which they're usually written, and which I struggle to avoid myself. Mostly, I hate trying to boil things down into overly simplistic terms. I was reading this interview with my brother-in-law, Stephen Henderson, by the Poynter Institute, which two years ago gave him an award for his editorial writing in the Baltimore Sun. The questioner asks if he's "opposed to editorials that say, 'On the one hand...' and 'On the other hand...'" Steve responds, "That's the kiss of death. ... You've got to get all that out of your mind before you sit down at the keyboard." His point is not that an argument should be boilerplate or take on straw men, just that it shouldn't be muddled. Still, in light of Kristof's column, I think that as long as opinion pieces end up at a solid conclusion, they should do a better job of illuminating the merit of two or three sides if they are to truly serve the public and not just rally an interest group.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
About Me
Labels
- 4 (14)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2003
(263)
-
▼
November
(33)
- This week in my B&C blog: Life after postmodernism...
- Happy Thansgiving , especially to my sister, a stu...
- It's the 40th anniversary of the Kennedy assassina...
- • Number of the Day: 10 Percent of children who wa...
- • Thought of the Day: negative self-affirmation Do...
- Other than the Panthers-Cowboys game, which will b...
- I want to keep track of these links to New Yorker ...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: ennead \EH-nee-ad\: a ...
- This week in my B&C blog: How "brights" are becomi...
- • Number of the Day: 308 National cable channels, ...
- • Thought of the Day: chronology and personal narr...
- By my count, 2 of this week's 16 NFL games pitted ...
- Recent New Yorker cartoons (more coming next week ...
- When novacaine makes you bi-lingual: My mouth was ...
- I was on hold with my credit card company yesterda...
- Nicholas Kristof's column this morning on ideology...
- This week in my B&C blog: A look back at Take Back...
- • Number of the Day: 2 million Approximate number ...
- • Thought of the Day: Does everyone keep to a comf...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: accoutrement\uh-KOO-te...
- Excerpt of NY Times article for my B&C blog: -Skip...
- • Number of the Day: 3 Cups of sugar in the averag...
- • Thought of the Day: The purpose of ambivalence "...
- Cheesy Jesus Marketing Watch: Jesus teething ring ...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: diluvial \duh-LOO-vee-...
- • Number of the Day: 200,000 Average annual income...
- • Thought of the Day: babies and idealism There's ...
- This week in my B&C blog: October news roundup: a ...
- My latest Tribune story: A sidebar for the Sunday ...
- • Number of the Day: 500,000 Dollars spent per yea...
- • Thought of the Day: Free as a bird? Is flying st...
- I panicked when I realized I forgot to tape the CB...
- • Etymology Today from M-W: impugn \im-PYOON\ : ...
-
▼
November
(33)
No comments:
Post a Comment